>Awards: who needs 'em?

>I'm bumping up this comment from a previous discussion because I think it brings up questions we can all usefully ponder. The mysterious shewhousually doesn'tdothistypeofthing wrote:

Suppose someone took it into her head to rank the dying and give awards for best last days or near to last days based on certain well thought out criteria, culminating in lots of sugarplums and press and endless discussion. How would that remove us from the experience? How would it remove us from the immediacy and all it might offer us. How would it remove the dying from it, distracted as they are by the possibility of this last big award? It is a toxic practice. There was a writer in East Germany who wrote there before and after the wall came down. Afterward everyone told her how wonderful that she had the opportunity now for artistic freedom, success, money. She said she had more freedom before the wall came down when she simply wrote, knowing her readership would be there, working in peace, nothing to aspire to. Now she had the great seduction of success, competition, it removed her from the freedom of the work. Suppose you could read books without having the distraction and removal to the level of judging them against each other. Then we would see what was there. Each its own experience because of what it is not because of where it is in the line up. Moving freely from book to book. I will not participate in these Newbery talks again. They are only a chance to say look how smart I am. I can tell you what is good better best. They have nothing to do with the truth. They have nothing to do with the artists' intent. Merry Christmas to all and to all a still night.


I don't know if I can read without judging, or at least comparing to what I've read before. (This got me kicked out of one those human-potential workshops once. The group leader said I was too judgmental. I asked her if she knew what I did for a living. Saved by literature once again!) And while I appreciate that the stakes being set up by prizes, or even reviews, can kill good writing, I also worry about a wafty world where all is "experience," there is no worse or better, each work of art is a distinct expression, la, la, la. Don't we write (or paint, etc.) in the first place to throw into relief those flashes of experience that, for us, are the important ones? Isn't living a process of making distinctions among choices? These are genuine questions, not rhetorical ploys, and I thank She... for bringing them up. Her example of the East German writer reminded me of a friend who was moving from the States to Mexico at a time (late 70s) when the Mexican government was cracking down on press freedoms and political dissent. My friend said "here I can wave my arms and say anything I want but nobody listens. There, at least, political speech matters."


Roger Sutton
Roger Sutton

Editor Emeritus Roger Sutton was editor in chief of The Horn Book, Inc., from 1996-2021. He was previously editor of The Bulletin of the Center for Children's Books and a children's and young adult librarian. He received his MA in library science from the University of Chicago in 1982 and a BA from Pitzer College in 1978.

33 COMMENTS
Comment Policy:
  • Be respectful, and do not attack the author, people mentioned in the article, or other commenters. Take on the idea, not the messenger.
  • Don't use obscene, profane, or vulgar language.
  • Stay on point. Comments that stray from the topic at hand may be deleted.
  • Comments may be republished in print, online, or other forms of media.
  • If you see something objectionable, please let us know. Once a comment has been flagged, a staff member will investigate.
Fill out the form or Login / Register to comment:
(All fields required)

Anonymous

>专业的翻译公司
深圳翻译公司中领先
深圳翻译公司提供
英语翻译
日语翻译
法语翻译
德语翻译
俄语翻译
藏语翻译
韩语翻译
泰语翻译
越南语翻译
维族语翻译
瑞典语翻译
印尼语翻译
阿拉伯语翻译
马来西亚语翻译
菲律宾语翻译
意大利语翻译
希腊语翻译
柬埔寨翻译
土耳其语语翻译
西班牙语翻译
葡萄牙语翻译
能源翻译
乌克兰翻译

地质翻译
合同翻译
法律翻译
机械翻译
标书翻译
医学翻译
外贸翻译
食品翻译
保险翻译
化工翻译
农业翻译
汽车翻译
通信翻译
建筑翻译
物流翻译
工程翻译

广州翻译公司
深圳翻译
翻译公司
深圳翻译公司
英语翻译
日语翻译
法语翻译
德语翻译
俄语翻译
藏语翻译
韩语翻译
泰语翻译
越南语翻译
印度语翻译
瑞典语翻译
印尼语翻译
阿拉伯语翻译
马来西亚语翻译
菲律宾语翻译
意大利语翻译
爱尔兰语翻译
柬埔寨翻译
土耳其语语翻译
西班牙语翻译
葡萄牙语翻译
外语翻译
小语种翻译
广州深圳同声传译|
证件翻译
合同翻译
法律翻译
机械翻译
标书翻译
医学翻译
外贸翻译
食品翻译
技术翻译
化工翻译
农业翻译
汽车翻译
通信翻译
英译汉,汉译英
汉译日,日译汉
金融翻译
新疆租车

珠海翻译公司|
佛山翻译公司|
惠州翻译公司
汕头翻译公司
三亚翻译公司
东莞翻译公司
深圳投影仪租赁|
口译|
深圳陪同翻译
翻译公司欢迎您的访问!
翻译公司|
北京翻译公司|
同声传译|
同传设备出租
会议设备租赁
同声传译
同传设备出租|
上海翻译公司|
北京翻译公司|
广州翻译公司

Posted : Mar 23, 2008 02:59


Andy Laties

>Mind you -- I don't believe that the best books are those written by people intentionally aspiring to win an award! The best books are written by people who are IGNORING such outside stimuli during the creative process! But we cannot dismiss the unconscious influence of the knowledge among artists that previous artists' work HAVE been recognized and HAVE had influence. Yes artists should forget about the audience during the creative process. But YES the future audience DOES have an influence DURING the creative process DESPITE the fact that the artist is "forgetting" about that audience.

We may pretend to be creating for ourselves alone. But we utilize the culture's language, do we not?

Andy

Posted : Dec 27, 2005 05:12


Andy Laties

>Well -- you would all have loved The Fat Cat if you'd seen it performed the way we did. Here's another one, written by an 8th Grader, on the subject of (as he informed us after our performance at his school) the homeless guys who used to hang around outside his uncle's liquor store. I sang this piece to the tune of "Parker's Mood"

The Boys On The Corner

Well, have you seen the boys on the corner,
With their shapeless pants, their tattered coats, and their threadbare dignity?
Young ladies avoid them,
Young boys annoy them,
And mothers chase them away.
With their paper sacks full of ambition,
And eyes that have seen much,
It's a kind of fellowship,
And even though they may be poorly dressed
And miss a few meals,
Did you ever wonder what it would be like to be one of the boys on the corner?

Now -- I'd agree with Jane that such pieces may well emerge from specific lessons in a creative writing curriculum. And -- certainly, just because I like that particular piece doesn't mean anyone else will (again: we did give this child an award, on stage) -- but -- I return to the central problem. Child's Play Touring Theatre reads a gigantic slush pile of a kind no publisher has ever seen. I mentioned that I personally read 20,000 pieces in 18 months I toured with them -- because during those years (1983-85) the company was handling 75,000 submissions per year. That number peaked in the early 90s, when we were seeing over 200,000 pieces per year! So over the company's 25 year history (founded 1978) we've handled millions of submissions, and the company still handles about 50,000 per year (we now ask each school to submit only a portion of the total written prior to each of our visits). So, we have file cabinets stuffed with pieces we've performed over the years: tens of thousands of pieces we've developed and toured from school to school (and for which we awarded Certificates Of Creativity during quite heightened, on-stage ceremonies -- like the Oscars!).

I'm certain those awards activities DID motivate children to aspire to become better writers. Many schools bring Child's Play in year after year: the same children are writing each year in hopes that their work will be performed by a familiar theatre troupe on stage.

Awards programs DO motivate authors, illustrators and publishers to do their very best.

Of course I agree that often the wrong artworks may win the awards, and terrific work may be ignored. This isn't the point. The entire culture simply pays more attention to the activity of creating art if there's some formalized mechanism (ritualistic) for focusing all of our attention, occasionally, SIMULTANEOUSLY on the simple fact that there are those striving to create excellent art, in our midst.

Andy Laties

Posted : Dec 27, 2005 04:35


rindambyers

>I love to critique books and debate issues dealign with books and tell people how much and why I might like or dislike a particular book, but I don't like "experts" making official judgements on books for me, the reader, like when award winning books get pushed into libraries to the neglect of other books I love to read.

I cannot see how any expert can tell me what tastes good for me. My husband loves a good steak. I hate a good steak and won't eat it. I don't like the taste of steak. I don't care about trying a new steak prepared in any which new way. And I have to live with me and what I taste. So therefore I rule in deciding what tastes good to me in what I read, awards or no awards. And yes, I think a great many excellent books get easily overlooked in awards and lists of best books. Tragically.

Posted : Dec 26, 2005 07:06


Jane

>Well, that segues into my rant on BRAVEHEART. I live part time in Scotland and I love the history and read it a lot. And let me tell you what a piece of crapola that movie is. No, I won't waste your time on all the historical inaccuracies, only to let you dwell for a moment (SPOILER AHEAD) on the unlikely scene where a man who has been drawn, hung, and about to be quartered (ie. hanged until he passes out, revived, and then ritually disembowled before being cut into four parts) sits up and cries out "Freedom
. . ." But the Scots adore the movie and now paint their faces blue at football games.

I suppose as epic, BRAVEHEART has great moments. Just as Homer was not historically accurate. And Dickens exploited (not exposed) the child labor and gin-swilling underbelly of England.

We shouldn't mix up entertainment with historical accuracy.

As to Andy (hi, dear!) and his child cat story, I am afraid I have to agree with Roger here. I run a yearly writing contest at the Hatfield, MA Elementary School and regularly find much better pieces than that. But again we are mixing up two things: the creative urge and the echoing mind. I bet that piece came from a teaching moment about Aesop's fables. I did an entire month online through Scholastic with kids writing Aesopian fables in rhyme. Some were better than others. (I critiqued them in rhyme.) But all were clearly by kids.

The Gordon Kormans and Susie Hintons (and Mozarts etc.) are the exceptions.
Have you read ERAGON? I read it in mss. A good try at a competant fantasy epic, and boy! could I tell what books the 15 year old author had been reading.

Jane

PS What do I think about awards? Love 'em when I get them, decry others. But ever since one of them--with a magnifying glass on top--set my good coat on fire, I have warned everyone: "Put your award where the sun doesn't shine."

Posted : Dec 25, 2005 12:58


View More Comments

RELATED 

ALREADY A SUBSCRIBER?

We are currently offering this content for free. Sign up now to activate your personal profile, where you can save articles for future viewing.

ALREADY A SUBSCRIBER?