Shake It Off!
by Vanessa Brantley-Newton; illus. by the author
Preschool, Primary    Paulsen/Penguin    32 pp.
6/24    9780525517115    $18.99
e-book ed.  9780525517122    $10.99

“This is a story that will have a happy ending, so don’t worry too much!” With that reassuring front-matter spoiler, Brantley-Newton launches into her tale about a little singing goat. Conflict is immediately introduced, as those around her despise the goat’s voice and dislike her penchant for climbing. Seemingly oblivious to others’ annoyance, she seeks adventure, only to fall into a deep, dry well. Making good use of the book’s materiality, Brantley-Newton offers an illustration that must be rotated ninety degrees for proper viewing, showing the goat at the bottom of the well and only the neighbors’ and animals’ feet visible up top. They’ve assembled after hearing her piteous cries but quickly abandon trying to save her, deciding instead to “give her a decent burial.” This alarming twist is softened by the established light and humorous tone of text and illustrations. “CAN YOU BELIEVE IT?” reads the all-caps print in bold colors as shovelfuls of dirt rain down on a close-up image of the beleaguered, incredulous goat. She’s also clever and resourceful as she shakes off the dirt and packs it down, singing to herself, “Shake it off. Pack it under!” A sequence of wordless panel illustrations shows the dirt rising under her hooves until she emerges, dirty but victorious, having gained new respect from her neighbors. The potential for the story (reminiscent of the parable of the donkey in the well) to be read metaphorically is encouraged by Brantley-Newton’s dedication to “every child who has been counted out” and her author’s note about overcoming childhood struggles with stuttering, dyslexia, and bullying.

From the July/August 2024 issue of The Horn Book Magazine.